If you’re profitable on paper but can’t tell how fast you can afford to grow, this episode will hit home.
In this episode of The Free to Grow CFO Podcast, Jon Blair sits down with Kevin Jornlin, one of Free to Grow’s CFOs, to give founders a practical guide to balance sheet health. They break down why the balance sheet matters whether or not you’re capital constrained today, how the cash conversion cycle determines how much of your profit actually shows up as cash, and why a big gap between your current ratio and quick ratio often points to excess inventory. They also tackle how much debt is too much, including a $14M brand that took on a $5M loan and survived because the founder had left $5M of equity in the business.
This episode gives you the balance sheet metrics to watch so more of your profit becomes cash you can reinvest or pay yourself.
Episode Links
Jon Blair - https://www.linkedin.com/in/jonathon-albert-blair/
Dylan Byers - https://www.linkedin.com/in/dylan-byers-046010149/
Free to Grow CFO - https://freetogrowcfo.com/
Aplo Group - https://www.aplogroup.com/
Key Takeaways
Overspending is the most common BFCM mistake, since holiday cohorts are often some of your lowest-LTV customers.
Set up campaigns to spend more than you need and cut back during the day, because chasing Meta to spend more rarely works.
Don’t abandon your year-round structure or first-order profitability guardrails; just push more volume through them.
Transcript
~~~~~~~~
00:30 Introduction to Black Friday Cyber Monday Strategies
03:05 Common Mistakes During BFCM
05:48 Understanding Performance Metrics
08:35 Inventory Management and Sales Strategy
10:59 Ad Spend and Campaign Structure
13:54 Final Thoughts on BFCM Performance Tracking
Jon Blair (00:30)
All right, we are back, and I've got my homie Dylan Byers from the Aplo group back on the show. Dylan, what's happening, man?
Dylan (00:39)
We were just saying before we started this recording, it's officially October, which is absolutely insane. So I guess we're, a few weeks away from a lot of Black Friday sales launching, but it's go time, Jon.
Jon Blair (00:51)
Dude, it's smelling like the holidays. We bought our first holiday offer product earlier this morning. You you wanna know what it was? This I'm this is gonna sound so dad of me, is a carpet cleaner that I've been that I've been looking at for a while and like the price dropped. I was like, and I and I've looked at my carpet earlier this morning. My kids were walking over the carpet with their shoes on in this one section that's really dirty. And I was like, I am buying that carpet cleaner today.
Dylan (01:06)
Yeah.
Jon Blair (01:21)
Let's go.
Dylan (01:21)
Is it a robot cleaner? Do they have those yet for carpets?
Jon Blair (01:24)
I'm sure they do. It is not. It is a good old-fashioned Hoover carpet cleaner. but I'm I'm excited. And it got me thinking, I want to talk today about Black Friday Cyber Monday, but I want to talk about something very, very specific, which is tactical tips for best practices on actually monitoring your performance during Black Friday Cyber Monday. You and I have talked a lot.
Dylan (01:29)
Let's go.
Jon Blair (01:52)
on our other podcast e-com scaling show about tracking data from a marketing performance perspective and how long you should wait versus when you should intervene. Black Friday Cyber Monday is like this special time where like you're pumping a lot of volume of ad dollars and sales in maybe like a four day period. And I just know that founders are all glued to their phones all Thanksgiving break in the States that whole weekend. and I want to talk and really get your honest opinion
About how founders should be thinking about this is the one time of year where it's like it's not just daily performance, it's like minute by minute performance, it's hourly performance. And I'm sure you guys get asked all the time, intra Black Friday, Cyber Monday, like, dude, should we make an adjustment? So that's what we're gonna chat about. Before we dive into several questions I have, what what do you think is the biggest trap or what do you experience during Black Friday Cyber Monday? What's the biggest trap or the most common kind of
mistake you see brand founders make on trying to like intervene too quickly during that sale period.
Dylan (02:58)
Yeah, I mean, I think one of the biggest mistakes, and it's a very simple one, is honestly overspending. So like this is a moment of profit realization more than it is necessarily like top of the funnel growth. It depends on your category. Some products that have a very short path to purchase that still exists. But if you look at the cohort analysis of BFCM, typically they're going to be some of your lowest lifetime value customers.
Jon Blair (03:04)
Mm.
Dylan (03:25)
Especially if it's predominantly people purchasing gifts. If it's people purchasing for themselves, a little bit different. But I'd say like I just see sometimes people chasing like bigger sales numbers on cohorts that don't necessarily math to to to the CAC or the new customer ROAS being achieved. So I'd say that's the most common mistake is just overspending on those specific days. having said that though, on the flip side of that, just to be super, super clear.
If you're a first-time customer dominant brand and you have a ton of incrementality on that day, a lot of stores still operate towards like a blended contribution margin or net margin as a percent. And I know you and I, Jon, have talked a lot about doing that more so to a dollar value. Like, how do we drive more profit dollars than percentage points of profit? And I have also seen stories less common, but I still see it. I still see some operators choose to underspend, in my opinion, on the day.
Because maybe they have like an arbitrary 20% like EBITDA target on the month. But if you're just making 10% over and over again, acquiring new customers with no degradation in efficiency, like that might be a day to go and do that at scale because that may be one of the days where you have the best incrementality in spend, to be very, very clear. I know it's a buzzword, but it's just like what is the relationship between more spend and new customer sales? So I'd say that most of the most of the time it's overspending.
But if you're that first-time customer dominant business, sometimes you can just go. And like I think that I've been doing this a long time now. I've been through I don't even know how many BFCMs, but coming up on like eight, seven, eight, something like that. And I feel like I've learned more lessons about not overspending. But I find some people who are maybe on BFCM one, two, or three.
sometimes you don't even know how much you can spend. So maybe you gotta spend too much before you learn not to spend too much. But like, yeah, that that's what I would say.
Jon Blair (05:20)
Yeah. There there's definitely some sort of human nature, law of human nature or human psychology that's definitely wrapped up in that. Because I've been through man, I gotta I've been through like 11 or so Black Friday Cyber Mondays. And we definitely, our first one at Guardian Bikes in 2015, I think it was, we definitely screwed up.
Dylan (05:30)
Yeah.
Jon Blair (05:48)
and overspent and okay so this is actually this leads to my first question. we should have in hindsight we should have known we're overspending. We actually let our agency at that time continue to say like, hey, just wait, just wait. It's coming. It's coming. And it it it didn't it it it smelled wrong to me at the time, but I was naive, right? And I was like, okay, these guys know they've they've done this a lot. We're we're in the middle of the sale period, like
Should it be mathing immediately in the day that you're in the middle of? Is there any waiting till later in the day or the next day? Like what are your thoughts on that?
Dylan (06:30)
Yeah, so this is where having multiple BFCMs under your belt is a strategic advantage to media spend planning, because it depends on what you're selling. So I'm gonna speculate that brands like Guardian Bikes, higher AOVs, durable, longer decision-making cycles. Let's say you're targeting the new customer as of two for simple math. It might actually make a ton of sense for you to spend the bulk of your month at 1.7 to 1.8.
Because the path to purchase arbitrarily for some high AOV brand might be on average three weeks. And, you know, especially in that lead up to DFCM, depending on how you structure your offer, you might want to kind of front run that a little bit below an efficiency target. That is not most brands. most brands should probably not be front-running like weeks in advance. Maybe like you want to look at things on a weekly basis, depending on your path to purchase on average. And to be very clear what I mean path to purchase.
is once someone clicks an ad for the first time, on average how many people buy that same day, the next day, a third, so on and so forth. And you can kind of understand the distribution and how much performance lag you can expect from your media spend. The trickier variable that's harder to prove is what's the lag between the first time someone sees an ad. Because you don't have that click data, that's even more a little bit less clear. But you have to think like this if you're going to like
front run some some lower efficiency with the expectation for more efficiency on the weekend. So I would say in general, if you have years and years of data, you might be able to do some analysis on what was the lags in your what were the lags in years past. And do you want to kind of spend into that? Because what I see some high AOV brands get wrong is they don't spend enough early and then they try to chase it at the end.
But really on BFCM for some of these longer consideration companies, you're literally just like farming the bottom of funnel and there's not much top of funnel happening. So if you haven't seeded your top of the funnel ahead of time, you're gonna have a harder time scaling efficiently. For most brands though, you're kind of just looking at it day to day, especially from like the Monday before US Thanksgiving through like early December, because every single day matters a lot. It doesn't mean you always have to make like
Dylan (08:51)
like like you know day trade too too much. But depending on how far off you are from target on the month and for the week and to the day, you still wanna make sure that things are pacing well.
Jon Blair (08:54)
Yeah.
Jon Blair (09:05)
It's interesting because the other consideration with a lot of brands, especially first time, especially new customer dominant brands and apparel brands, because there's more inventory risk there, right? We talk a lot about this on the e com scaling show that generally those are more risky than consumable or high LTV brands because when you exit the holidays, you don't have a subscriber base to draw down, you know, overstocked inventory positions. You gotta exit the holidays like
With as much inventory moved off your balance sheet as possible. And so there is this like, hey, here's our plan in terms of what I think our CAC or our efficiency is going to be on spend. And here's how much I think we're going to spend. And ultimately, that yields how many units I think we're going to sell, right? And ul ultimately our balance sheet position. If you're behind from a spend or let's say you're behind from an efficiency perspective, I have had to, in the middle of the sale before, get with an agency and say, hey,
Dylan (09:48)
Yeah.
Jon Blair (10:02)
I I understand that we're behind where we were hoped we could be at this spend level. I would I need you to keep spending because it is still contribution margin positive, even though it's not as positive as we want it to be. And I cannot end this holiday season overstocked on this inventory, even though the return is gonna be lower than I thought. And so I just that's an important call out I wanna make that like you should not overlook that if you are an apparel brand or a durable goods brand, trying to scale through this period.
Dylan (10:30)
A hundred percent. I I I've seen brands in that situation spending well above a hundred K a day trying to move units at break even just because of the obsolescence risk of season. like big brands get it wrong too. So
Jon Blair (10:45)
Totally, totally. And it's okay. It's it's I you know w it's about living to fight another day. It's not about nailing it perfectly, right? And so like you you have to when you go into a a compressed seasonal spike in sales like this, right? you do your best to to create a plan and place the best bets that you can. But once you're in the middle to use a poker analogy, when you're in the middle of playing a hand and your chips are already on the table.
At that point, just with whatever time or whatever moves you have left, you've just got to make the best of it. Even though if you find yourself in the middle of the hand and you're like, dang, this is not what I thought it was gonna be. And so it then becomes about the incremental impact of the decisions that are available to you, even though not every decision you were hoping was gonna be available is in the moment. And so you gotta then look at the new decision set or the new set of decisions you could make and say,
I'm gonna make the one that has the best incremental impact. I gotta, I gotta get rid of the sunk cost fallacy here and put that behind me, you know? So what is or may maybe the right way to ask this next question is how often are you guys on the agency side checking in on the performance during this Friday to Monday period BFCM and deciding if
maybe you've reached a decision point, you need to sync with the client about we need to push harder, we need to pull back.
Dylan (12:16)
Yeah, it it really depends on the business. I mean, like those days in particular, like like we're tracking and like looking at performance every hour, but it's it's also really easy to try to do too much in those days. I I'll say this most people are gonna primarily spend on meta ads. Meta ads are set up in such a way where they run seven day click attribution.
And that means meta's trying to basically get you an objective over a week-long period. So what sometimes happens is you might have some underspend on that day, you might have some overspend on that day. The worst situation you can be in is chasing, trying to get meta to spend more. So we have some clients
Jon Blair (12:57)
Mm-hmm.
Jon Blair (13:07)
yeah, dude, that is I've seen that happen so many times and like it's brutal.
Dylan (13:12)
Yeah. So we have some clients where we fully run cost caps, we have some clients where you run no cost caps, and we have some clients where we run both. That's that's a whole other tangent of media bind philosophies. But what I will say is regardless of the bid type you are running, you probably want to enter into Black Friday s with a campaign structure.
Jon Blair (13:26)
Yeah.
Dylan (13:40)
That is likely to produce more spend than you want and then cut back instead of trying to chase. you can o and the reason why is because how Meta's trying to pace is it's trying to, yes, if you're doing seven-day optimization, it's trying to average it over a weekly period, but it does have this daily parameter that it can live within. So I always say you're better off going big and then cutting than not going big enough and then trying to chase by launching new campaigns, so on and so forth.
Jon Blair (14:11)
Make sense.
Dylan (14:11)
So ideally on those weekend days, you're basically doing the following. You're prepping your spend on Thursday, probably launching that budget late into the evening going into Friday. So you, you know, you're not looking to increase. You're looking if you have to cut really. And you know, there's gonna be cases when you increase, but time and time again during Black Friday, it is tough to get spent to basically go midday. and then you're probably looking at your historical trends for Saturday, Sunday, Monday.
For how you basically pay spend over the weekend. Cause also what you don't want to do is, you know, typically the peaks are Friday and Monday. Different brands have different higher performance days. Most brands we see Fridays bigger than Monday these days. And then the weekend, you know, can vary a little bit. But a lot of brands are, you know, making big adjustments over the weekend too to ramp down and then ramp up, especially if they're not running cost caps. But even if you're running cost caps over a seven day attribution window.
This time of year has a little bit more nuance in terms of how Meta actually chooses to pay spend due to how cost caps work. I'll add one more thing. Some people during this period of time who run cost caps will opt to also run highest volume or highest value bidding with no cap. I think that's totally fine. so another variable that some people will opt to do is they'll move from seven-day click click attribution to one-day click attribution.
You can kind of force Meta to try to optimize on the day instead of the week. I'm less of a fan of that one based off of my experience, but I do know people who run it. I think what you do is heavily dependent on how you currently run your account. Is it cost controls? Is it seven-day click, one-day view? Is it seven-day click? Is it incremental attribution? There's really not one size fits all approach other than the way in which you structure your campaigns should probably be more.
than what you're expecting to, so you can cut back throughout the day, not chase. All the other stuff, it's nitty gritty. but the big one is plan to spend.
Jon Blair (16:15)
Yeah, that's interesting. And you kind of hinted at this a little bit, but we we talked about this in a different e-com scaling episode, like maybe a couple of weeks ago. But just like about how you don't want to vastly depart from whatever your kind of structure and guidelines and guardrails are all throughout the year. You're just pushing more volume through that structure. And like I kept mentioning on that podcast episode the concept of like if you have a first order profitability target with a with some sort of a CAC ceiling.
Dylan (16:31)
Hundred percent.
Jon Blair (16:44)
Cause you're a new customer dominant brand, we might adjust that because the promotion and the because your variable cost, including the cost of a promotion, are slightly different, right? During this time of year. But we're ultimately gonna still adhere to this like minimum level of first order profitability, right? at a unit economic level. We're not gonna depart from that just because it's Black Friday, Cyber Monday. And so that would be honestly like my biggest piece of advice.
As you're tactically watching your performance it throughout B BFCM is like you're just pushing more volume through the structure and the systems financially and growth marketing wise that you've done all year, right? And you're just adjusting them for the few variables that are unique during this time period on the on the you know on the marketing side, you're spending a lot more in a four-day period. And on the finance side,
you are you you're holding a lot more inventory going into this and you're also your unit economics are slightly different because of sh you know peak shipping charges and because of the the cost of the promotion. But in
Dylan (17:52)
Tot totally, total totally agree. Just to add on one thing on that, I think for most brands, their structure should not change at all. I think most of the time you can basically get away with running the same core structure, just pushing more spend going into the kind of peak weekend. I think cost caps accounts have the biggest changes for those days because of how meta functionally bids when you have a cost cap. So if you're doing highest volume, highest value, which I think is still the vast majority of brands.
You can probably run your same setup. if you're running cost caps, target ROAS bid caps, you probably have to make larger changes going into the weekend.
Jon Blair (18:31)
So, Dylan, what are your final thoughts on this topic of of tactically watching performance throughout Black Friday, Cyber Monday?
Dylan (18:40)
make sure you're tracking gross margin by day or contribution margin by day, not based off of an a historical discount assumption. Make sure you're actually getting like real ⁓ P&L quality metrics to the day, because the biggest mistake I've seen for BFCM isn't actually the weekend. It is the entire sale assuming a certain gross margin profile, running a discount, and then getting a wildly different outcome after adjusting for shipping costs and and and
Jon Blair (19:06)
Wildly wildly different.
Dylan (19:09)
Yeah. So that's the one that I see the most when talking to brands about past BFCM failures. And like it's a little bit annoying to track, especially if you have a lot of SKUs, but the tech now makes it fairly easy. so I would say that's the single biggest one. How about you, Jon?
Jon Blair (19:27)
Yeah, ⁓ honestly, it'll just it's just the the reiteration of ⁓ if your P&L plan, if you find yourself in the middle of BFCM and your P&L plan is clearly off track as you're halfway through, you then probably need to shift to your balance sheet plan and say, We may not be able to optimize or for or we may not be able to maximize the P&L here, but can we maximize the best?
two-dimensional financial benefit between doing the best we can on profit maximization, but then also the best we can on cash flow maximization and specifically around making sure we don't end the year like too long on inventory. So anyways man, I'm excited. We are mere weeks away, which is crazy. And I know it so I appreciate you coming on man and I look forward to the next chat.
Dylan (20:17)
Yeah, it's wild.
Dylan (20:22)
Awesome. Thanks, Jon.